Price Check: Braden Schneider
Two bridge deals in, Braden Schneider is stuck on the third pair and headed for restricted free agency. What does his next contract look like—and where?
What’s there to say about Braden Schneider that hasn’t already been said? I’ve written about it, Chip’s written about it, Eric previewed him this season. Selected 19th overall in the 2020 NHL draft after the New York Rangers traded up to pick him, Schneider has been an everyday part of the Rangers lineup since he debuted in the 2021-22 season.
It's been a tale of two cities regarding Schneider's tenure in New York. Across his first two seasons, he looked like he had all the potential in the world. In more recent campaigns, he's been a non-factor. The shoulder injury and prolonged surgery have played a key role in his decline, but we're at the point in his career where excuses can't be made.
Performance to Start the Season
Through the first quarter of the season, Schneider has no goals, two assists, and 12 penalty minutes with a -3 rating. That's a whole lot of nothing for someone who, at this point in his career, was expected to be at least a second-pairing defenseman.
Recently, Schneider has been exactly that, but only by default as a result of the injuries Sean Durzi and Alberts Smits have dealt with. At full health, Schneider has been locked on the team's third pairing alongside Smits. While you can certainly make the case that Schneider's experience has been helpful to have on a pair with a rookie, you can also make the case that Smits has, more often than not, looked like the more competent NHL defenseman. That's valid given Smits' draft stock, but not a great look for Schneider.
I've written extensively on this in the past: Schneider has no real role on this team. He's kind of a "mini-Trouba" (which at this point isn't a compliment), he's kind of a defensively responsible player, he has some offensive elements to his game, and he's good for at least one noteworthy hit in approximately one of every 10 games. In the right setting, he can be a valuable role player on any team's blue line. At this moment in time, he's simply not accomplishing that for the Rangers.
Right now, 20 games into his fifth full season with the Rangers, he continues to be in no man's land and isn't doing anything in his forced promotion to show that he's a player worthy of a long-term investment.